He wanted to argue outside the context of Christianity.
So I told him to repent.
You are viewing a single comment's thread. View all
0
el_hoovy on scored.co
1 year ago0 points(+0/-0)1 child
it doesn't seem like you have a coherent point: "jews can repent, but the sentiment that they cannot repent because statistically speaking they practically never do is valid, but that sentiment is wrong and makes you look like a fool"
either we're allowed to make generalizations or we aren't. i'll gladly say "jews can't repent" and then congratulate Brother Nathanael for repenting in the same breath - i don't think i'm a hypocrite or doublethinking, i'm just generalizing and then recognizing an exception, which not only are separate events but ought be kept separate deliberately.
what you're doing when you rebuke us for that generalization is that you're taking the exception *as* the rule, which is a classic modern mistake best avoided. the more exceptional you keep exceptions, the better you defend your main point. if you don't do that, you risk aiding an enemy just in case he might be an exception.
I rescind my criticism if that's your position. Maybe it's just late stage autism, but when I read an absolute statement such as "X can't Y," I always take it at face value. I know a lot of Christians do hold that as a literal opinion as well which further muddies the water.
yeah, most people here are reasonable about it in the final analysis. there's some that do take a hard stance like you describe but i've faith that it's just their spirit getting the better of them when they feel they're among like-minded people and can state their opinions, and that in a real scenario if ever we stood to watch a jew *truly* repent they would be able to read the room and not pull out a luger and execute him.
it should be noted though that nowadays it's particularly difficult and extreme for a jew to repent. given that they are born into jewish institutions and ways of life, which are an injustice against nature from beginning to end, they have a lot to actively undo as adults. it's not enough to stop liking clipping coins and usury - they need to take up a life of pointing out how messed up their kin is to really prove they've understood the whole ordeal and are against it.
you'll see very many jews going "yeah, we're pieces of shit, what are you going to do about it?" and very few saying "yeah, we're pieces of shit, and i'd like to help you stop that somehow" because it's so damn hard to go against stuff hammered into you since birth even if you're consciously aware of it. look up the documentary "Defamation", it's on YouTube, and it shows how they basically traumatize and gaslight their own schoolchildren to get them to believe in the whole jewish worldview. it's no wonder most of them don't repent.
either we're allowed to make generalizations or we aren't. i'll gladly say "jews can't repent" and then congratulate Brother Nathanael for repenting in the same breath - i don't think i'm a hypocrite or doublethinking, i'm just generalizing and then recognizing an exception, which not only are separate events but ought be kept separate deliberately.
what you're doing when you rebuke us for that generalization is that you're taking the exception *as* the rule, which is a classic modern mistake best avoided. the more exceptional you keep exceptions, the better you defend your main point. if you don't do that, you risk aiding an enemy just in case he might be an exception.
it should be noted though that nowadays it's particularly difficult and extreme for a jew to repent. given that they are born into jewish institutions and ways of life, which are an injustice against nature from beginning to end, they have a lot to actively undo as adults. it's not enough to stop liking clipping coins and usury - they need to take up a life of pointing out how messed up their kin is to really prove they've understood the whole ordeal and are against it.
you'll see very many jews going "yeah, we're pieces of shit, what are you going to do about it?" and very few saying "yeah, we're pieces of shit, and i'd like to help you stop that somehow" because it's so damn hard to go against stuff hammered into you since birth even if you're consciously aware of it. look up the documentary "Defamation", it's on YouTube, and it shows how they basically traumatize and gaslight their own schoolchildren to get them to believe in the whole jewish worldview. it's no wonder most of them don't repent.