New here?
Create an account to submit posts, participate in discussions and chat with people.
Sign up
You are viewing a single comment's thread. View all
TallestSkil on scored.co
11 days ago 2 points (+0 / -0 / +2Score on mirror ) 1 child
Neat, but why do we have to wait to do that? Do you need permission or something?
JustifiedReprobate on scored.co
11 days ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror ) 1 child
I understand some of the sentiment of your comment, and I've reflected on this phenomenon for a while... perhaps there is simply no realistic conception of what constructive action would look like... and to do that require exchanging ideological performance for ordinary responsibilities, which can be difficult, tedious, and unglamorous...

The romanticization of collective identity, ancestral sacrifice, national solidarity, and historical continuity is probably a result of a remarkably individualist, confined, and reserved personality. He has to encounter actual human beings as unpleasant as that may be initially... and build intentional communities... An imagined community cannot disappoint you in the way a real community inevitably will.

An imagined people are courageous, honorable, loyal, and united. Actual people are disagreeable, selfish, imperfect, and occasionally exhausting. They make demands on your time. They require forgiveness, compromise, and patience. An imagined community cannot disappoint you in the way a real community inevitably will.

And the attempts to establish something on purity will inevitably disappoint.

He has to do it for the ones he loves. But first, he has to learn to love something beyond an idea. And when a man genuinely loves others, he does not need permission to assume responsibility for their well-being. He willingly bears considerable personal expense because their flourishing matters more to him than his own comfort.

His inaction isn't necessarily the result of cowardice, complacency, or an unwillingness to sacrifice. It's that he has no one for whom he feels compelled to sacrifice... He is waiting for something worthy of his love to appear, without understanding that love is what makes something worth building in the first place.

I believe the contradiction is he longs for a community defined by mutual devotion, but has made the existence of such a community a prerequisite for offering his own.

Further, nobody should be expected to destroy their own life, much less the lives of others, merely to demonstrate the sincerity of an ideology. There is a distinction between being willing to sacrifice for something one loves and being willing to destroy something one hates. Courage cannot supply a purpose where none exists. Nor can destruction create the relationships, obligations, and mutual affection that were absent beforehand...

He cannot love his people into existence by first destroying the world around him. He has to begin loving the people who already exist within it.

And if he cannot do that, what exactly is the imagined future supposed to accomplish for him?

We should not goad eachother to action on an abstraction... that is irresponsible and self-defeating... I think its why the ethnonationalist struggles. It creates resentment and paralysis instead of love.
TallestSkil on scored.co
11 days ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror ) 1 child
>perhaps there is simply no realistic conception of what constructive action would look like

Maybe that’s our problem. Can’t achieve a goal if you don’t know what it looks like.

>An imagined community cannot disappoint you in the way a real community inevitably will.

I’ll take a real whites-only community–warts and all–over any community, real or imagined, that is multiracial. We can deal with the real *future* problems effortlessly when we don’t have the real *present* problems–orders of magnitude worse–at hand.

>…he has to learn to love something beyond an idea. And when a man genuinely loves others, he does not need permission to assume responsibility for their well-being.

Note the problem here, specifically with regard to the current socioeconomic conditions around courtship.

>He cannot love his people into existence by first destroying the world around him.

What if the world is not of him?

>We should not goad eachother to action on an abstraction

There’s nothing abstract about “Hey, uh, for the last 15,000 years we had whites-only communities and created literally all of human civilization, but about 100 years ago we were told we can’t do that anymore and everything is collapsing now. Maybe we should demand all nonwhites get out and force it to happen?"
JustifiedReprobate on scored.co
11 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 ) 1 child
>Maybe that’s our problem. Can’t achieve a goal if you don’t know what it looks like.

Right - identifying a desired demographic outcome is not the same as developing a constructive vision of society. But I think that is where the ethnonationalist typically starts, so the vision of society is cloudy.

What our institutions look like? How would we cultivate responsibility, maintain families, resolve disputes, sustain economic relationships, or overcome the isolation that presently characterizes their lives?... which brings us to the next point...

>We can deal with the real future problems *effortlessly* when we don’t have the real present problems

Right, but I've highlighted "effortlessly" because this is the kind of idealization I'm criticizing... I imagine you've met some particularly passionate Whites in your life that you do not get along well with. Europe has been defined by endless brother conflict. Even if the preferred demographic arrangement somehow existed, the actual work of community would remain. I believe it is more difficult to cultivate a community than to destroy. And I think it is important to have a community first before implementing destruction.

>specifically with regard to the current socioeconomic conditions around courtship.

Worthy of examination for sure - but I'm also talking friendship, neighborliness, mutual assistance, religious congregations, voluntary associations, and intergenerational responsibilities are all expressions of communal life... Can we treat community as an eventual reward for achieving political objectives; or is community something that is practiced with intention so that political objectives are achieved?

>What if the world is not of him?

If this is a deliberate invocation of Christ or Christian doctrine... The Christian is not of the world precisely because his conduct within it is supposed to reflect a different moral order. The Christian does not need the world to belong to him before he can love his neighbor.

If a man refuses to exercise responsibility toward the people around him because the world is not sufficiently his own, then his conception of community has become almost entirely conditional upon political circumstances.

>Maybe we should demand all nonwhites get out and force it to happen?

An action does not become realistic or constructive simply because it is specific.

If one has located the source of his dissatisfaction outside himself, identified a population whose removal resolves it, and subordinated ordinary constructive responsibilities to that objective... I think it creates for him a psychologically convenient scenario because it indefinitely postpones the demanding work of community formation.

Suppose you achieved precisely the ethnonationalist society you wanted tomorrow. What would you actually do differently for the people around you that you are unwilling or unable to do today?
TallestSkil on scored.co
11 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 )
>this is the kind of idealization I'm criticizing

Sorry; I *do* mean “in comparison.” Compared to the problem of perpetually wrangling the food, medical, and criminological needs of tens of millions of niggers, the issues a city of *only* whites face is as nothing.

Remember, Andy Griffith had two cops for the whole city for a reason.

*“Rosy-eyed idealism from a franchise written by jews?”*

Well… the idea came from life in some form.

Can’t reply fully now. Want to later. I’ll probably forget. Remind me if you do reply. Hate myself.
Toast message