Got "No True Scotsman"'d recently for suggesting Leftist women claiming to be Christian are just as Christian as a jew claiming to be an Icelander. They have no affiliation with the faith beyond the name when they betray core tennets and >2000 years of faith and tradition. The "No True Scotsman" fallacy retort is overused, and this is another case where I think category error is the true observation, not a mischaracterization fallacy.