You are viewing a single comment's thread. View all
1
devotech2 on scored.co
19 days ago1 point(+0/-0/+1Score on mirror)2 children
Is nuance no longer allowed? Why can't we talk about things hitler *did* do wrong? Even internet tankies are willing to discuss shit that stalin did wrong (to them at least, so that means usually the things stalin was actually correct about).
Anyways, what's the purpose of dogmatic adherence to hiterlism as an immutable science? That isn't very good politicking. We've had some 80 odd years of insight and ability to look into the inner workings of everything hitler and his associates did and improve upon it. Im not even saying that the first commenter is even necessarily correct in his analysis, but we kind of should have some ability to sit down and say "okay, hitler fucked up X, Y, and Z. How can we do better?"
On the topic of Christianity in germany, here's a criticism of hitler: positive Christianity was a fucking stupid and heretical idea full of postmodernist nu-spiritual slop and it didn't work at all. There, a real criticism of something hitler did (or at least supported). Let's not repeat that disaster.
I agree, hitler was good, but to screed "he did absolutely nothing wrong ever and was a saint" is to forget the entire point. Hitler himself could have done the same thing with kaiser wilhelm or even Drexler but didn't.
Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed
I never said he was perfect. He let non-Whites in and was way too soft on jews, other non-Whites and gays. He should have done Christianity more dogmatically and traditionally, but he never killed "Catholic Priests" or whatever the jews say.
Good take, many on our side fall into the traps and bad habits that poison everyone's thinking. Adolf would not want us to recreate his movement 1:1 because our needs and threats are different.
Anyways, what's the purpose of dogmatic adherence to hiterlism as an immutable science? That isn't very good politicking. We've had some 80 odd years of insight and ability to look into the inner workings of everything hitler and his associates did and improve upon it. Im not even saying that the first commenter is even necessarily correct in his analysis, but we kind of should have some ability to sit down and say "okay, hitler fucked up X, Y, and Z. How can we do better?"
On the topic of Christianity in germany, here's a criticism of hitler: positive Christianity was a fucking stupid and heretical idea full of postmodernist nu-spiritual slop and it didn't work at all. There, a real criticism of something hitler did (or at least supported). Let's not repeat that disaster.
I agree, hitler was good, but to screed "he did absolutely nothing wrong ever and was a saint" is to forget the entire point. Hitler himself could have done the same thing with kaiser wilhelm or even Drexler but didn't.
Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed