New here?
Create an account to submit posts, participate in discussions and chat with people.
Sign up
51
The truth about fat. (media.scored.co)
posted 21 days ago by EJGeneric on scored.co (+0 / -0 / +51Score on mirror )
You are viewing a single comment's thread. View all
13
devotech2 on scored.co
21 days ago 13 points (+0 / -0 / +13Score on mirror ) 2 children
Nothing makes you fat besides calories. Calories make you fat. Eating more calories than you burn makes you fat. That's the end of the story as far as what makes you fat. It gets more complicated when you look into the satiety of certain foods and how caloric content makes almost no difference in the ability of food to satiate your body whatsoever. One boiled potato has slightly fewer calories than a can of soda. Obviously the potato is going to make you feel full, conversely, you can basically drink soda indefinitely. Just one example. A lot of the fattening foods actually aren't that much higher in calories than healthy food, but they're nutritionally void. They're effectively pre-digested. Your body still feels hungry after consuming them, which leads to overeating and eventually being fat. Even if you eat one slop meal, still feel hungry, and then eat a healthy meal to feel full (which almost nobody does), you're still overconsuming calories even if not nutrients.

When looking at macronutrients in broad categories: proteins trump fats in satiety, but carbs are weird and highly variable in satiety, even though all carbs contain 4 calories per gram (except fiber). Fiber is the most satiating macro of all, while you can eat refined sugar until you drop dead and not be full. After fiber would be complex carbs, and after that (before refined sugar) would be simple processed carbs. Micronutrients play a smaller but still very important role in satiety by keeping the metabolic and hormonal systems running properly, even if they aren't processed for energy at all.

Alcohol is also a macronutrient too by the way, but alcohol is the most empty type of calorie you can possibly consume. Even moreso than refined sugar. It's useless for the body.

Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed
tchouk on scored.co
21 days ago 2 points (+0 / -0 / +2Score on mirror ) 2 children
The calories you eat don't matter at all. Eat a pound of sugar and fat wrapped in a condom every day and see how quick you gain weight.

It is the calories you metabolize, which is totally different than the retarded number on the label.

Energy metabolism is a very complicated and complex system and has almost nothing to do with the little number they get by burning shit in a calorimeter
devotech2 on scored.co
21 days ago 7 points (+0 / -0 / +7Score on mirror ) 1 child
Every metabolism is different but it absolutely rings true in a majority of cases that weight loss/gain is calories in - calories out. If I drink a pack of soda a day and then quit, without changing anything else about my diet (assuming my diet is fine), I'll lose weight. There are some freaks out there that never gain weight and some that gain weight at the drop of a hat, but they're exceptions. There's no need to overcomplicate this when regarding people who should just lose weight. The food and the amount that they eat causes them to get fat, ostensibly because it's highly calorific and not nourishing. So they should eat less of it and eat better lower calorie foods that make them feel fuller.

How fast something is metabolized is related to the complexity of the macro. More complex macros = more difficult to digest = more satiety. Processing reduces the complexity of macros which leads to more consumption.

It is actually *very easy* to simply lose weight if weight loss is all you care about and not your overall health (which if you're a lardass, slimming down *will* improve your overall health no matter what, so that should be your priority). Just eat less. Following the number on the tin works fine for most people. Eat less and count calories. Worry about the more complex aspects of food when you're already at a healthy weight. If you're fat, your priority should be to lose fat. Which can be done by following the tin.

I think calories are a fine baseline for measuring this anyways. It's impossible to measure precisely how a certain food will be processed into ATP (or not). Calories are the best rough estimate that you can really get. ATP is energy and calories are the only form of energy that it makes sense and is possible to convert food into. Every food is flammable when dehydrated because all macros are flammable because all of them are energy stores. The margin for error primarily lies in water content, because the number on the tin is made with dehydrated food due to the fact that moisture makes it impossible to burn, and thus impossible to measure energy. But really, following the number should help you lose more weight than if it were actually accurate. The serving size on "x" product has a higher calorific value than in actuality. This also applies to calories that cannot be digested from food. The calorific value on the tin overshoots it rather than the inverse. Which is much better than the alternative.

Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed
tchouk on scored.co
21 days ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror ) 1 child
You could eat 10k of "calories" in fat every day and if you only ate only the pure fat and nothing else, never gain a pound because the body just gets rid of the excess energy it doesn't need through waste. If you are peeing out ketones, your body is literally getting rid of calories without metabolizing any of them. I've done the experiment on myself using a ketone meter and glucose mobitor to track things.

Blood glucose on the other hand can only be metabolized in exactly one of three ways: either directly by muscle action, glycogen creation or fat synthesis and it absolutely *must* be metabolized or you die. Which means eating 10k "calories" of sugar will have a wildly different effect on your body compared to the fat.

And that isn't even going into the myriad of unknown and poorly studied effects of bacteria and gut health on all these processes.

So it is about energy balance, obviously, but what constitutes "energy in" is way more difficult than just some number on the label created from our understanding of metabolism in the late 19th century
devotech2 on scored.co
21 days ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror ) 1 child
>You could eat 10k of "calories" in fat every day and if you only ate only the pure fat and nothing else, never gain a pound because the body just gets rid of the excess energy it doesn't need through waste. If you are peeing out ketones, your body is literally getting rid of calories without metabolizing any of them. I've done the experiment on myself using a ketone meter and glucose mobitor to track things.

Sure enough, but literally nobody is doing that and that's a good way to end up dying from lack of any other nutrient besides fat. If you eat fat with other things, the calorific value of the fat does matter. Goy-oil is essentially pure fat too, but it's a big contributor to weight gain because of how many extra calories it puts in your food.

>Which means eating 10k "calories" of sugar will have a wildly different effect on your body compared to the fat.

Because the macro itself does different things entirely than what lipids do of course. Much less so to do with the calories than the function of the thing containing the calories. Every macro does a different thing, I'm sure you already know this though. They're far more than just energy stores or else there'd be no difference between any of them besides how many calories they have.

>So it is about energy balance, obviously, but what constitutes "energy in" is way more difficult than just some number on the label created from our understanding of metabolism in the late 19th century

Factual, and I don't disagree. The problem is just that a better system to my knowledge, which can tell the average layman about how fat a certain food is gonna make him become, doesn't really exist. So it's generally good guidance for the average person that doesn't eat 10k calories of exclusively sugar or exclusively fat a day.

Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed
tchouk on scored.co
21 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 ) 1 child
Fair enough, agreed on most points.

But I think the even easier way to maintain a good body and healthy just basically boils down to "don't eat processed goy slop and avoid mixing fat with carbs in a single meal"
WeedleTLiar on scored.co
21 days ago 2 points (+0 / -0 / +2Score on mirror ) 1 child
Is it?

I eat 2000 calories, I burn 2000 calories, my weight stays the same.
tchouk on scored.co
20 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 )
The joules you put in your mouth and the joules your body uses aren't the number on the package.

Like grass has a lot of energy if you measure the calories in a calorimeter. Cows can get fat of off grass and horses can spend huge amounts of energy eating grass. Grass in a calorimeter is going to give you something like 400 calories per 100 grams, same as pure sugar

You'll die of starvation eating grass.
ShekelJa on scored.co
21 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 ) 1 child
Where are the calorie receptors?
devotech2 on scored.co
21 days ago 6 points (+0 / -0 / +6Score on mirror ) 1 child
Calories are measured by the thermal energy produced by a thing (not just food) when set on fire. The more the water temperature raises, the more calories that thing has. Each degree kelvin that water raises is 1 calorie. Energy is required by living things and machines to function. Your body does the same thing that setting food on fire does by processing it into ATP.

Calories are like gasoline. You burn them for energy like a car does (gas also has a calorific value too). Your cells move, it's impossible for there to be movement without energy. The energy is provided by ATP, like how in a car the movement of your pistons is powered by exploding gasoline. The difference is that gas stays gas in a car, and if you overfill it it just spills out. Your body turns excess calories into fat for storage. But you can't have only calories, because you need more to function than that. If you based your diet solely on calorie-maxxing for maximum energy, you're going to feel like shit and then die. Like how a car needs more than just gas or else you'll just destroy it. Plenty of energy is available if the gas tank is full, but if you don't have oil and coolant in all the right places a full tank is pretty fucking useless.

Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed
ShekelJa on scored.co
21 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 ) 1 child
Not sure if AI or knowledgeable. And yes, fuck israel. Only other thing I will add to your rhetoric is the physiology behind weight and health. It is not meant to invalidate calories or energy balance, but instead meant to contextualize the situation under a different lens. This is important because there are unusual outcomes that have been observed that cannot reliably be explained in depth using calories alone.

For example, as observed by many but never thoroughly validated, are people who eat less and move more and lose no weight. Impossible from an energy standard, suggesting they miscalculated. However, I hypothesize that their metabolic health is badly maligned to the extent that the body preferentially burns less energy rather than utilizes stored fat. so to avoid the eat-less-burn-less outcome, greater depth must complement energy balance.

Thus, maintaining energy balance while also considering insulin, ghrelin, cortisol, and adrenalin behavior is probably one of the more effective ways of addressing health and weight without falling into unusual setbacks.
devotech2 on scored.co
21 days ago 0 points (+0 / -0 )
>Not sure if AI or knowledgeable

Not AI. So I'll take it as a compliment

>For example, as observed by many but never thoroughly validated, are people who eat less and move more and lose no weight. Impossible from an energy standard, suggesting they miscalculated. However, I hypothesize that their metabolic health is badly maligned to the extent that the body preferentially burns less energy rather than utilizes stored fat. so to avoid the eat-less-burn-less outcome, greater depth must complement energy balance.

Ah, it's not too uncommon. It's the body doing what it's supposed to in the most annoying way. It's a starvation signal telling your metabolism to slow down. This is usually caused by people doing too much too fast. Or by people not adjusting their nutrient intake in accordance with the goal. The fix for this is usually to cut calories more (a bit risky), increase physical activity, and eat more thermic foods (fiber and protein) which burn significantly more calories to process (also related to satiety).

Furthermore, I consider that Israel must be destroyed
Toast message