You are viewing a single comment's thread. View all
13
disoriented on scored.co
13 days ago13 points(+0/-0/+13Score on mirror)5 children
The entirety of both the existence of Muhammad and the Quran are fraudulent. There likely was a man like Muhammad who was the focal point of a religiously fanatical army he motivated, but everything said about him was written decades after he died. The Arabic scriptures themselves have and provenance that is more suspect than either the Aramaic or Greek scriptures and were filtered through only a few people who did selective editing when they compiled them.
My source for this is Robert Spencer, who has written extensively on these subjects.
13 days ago5 points(+0/-0/+5Score on mirror)1 child
I understand there were several Korans at one point, and shortly after Mohammed's death, a high-ranking Muslim leader ordered all but 1 of them destroyed. There's no "higher criticism" of the Koran like there is of the Bible. But that may not mean much. I don't think higher criticism of the Bible has done anything but let leftists pat themselves on the back at their own cleverness.
Criticism of the Bible (at least real vulgate translations) is just jews attempting to destroy our collective Christian Identity so they can replace it with fraudulent abominations like the Scofield Bible, which should be burned publicly.
12 days ago3 points(+0/-0/+3Score on mirror)2 children
When it comes to Islam, everything, literally EVERYTHING, we know about Mohammed comes hundreds and hundreds of years after he lived, and even then, the information does not correspond at all with archaeological or historical evidence. There is so little evidence of Mohammed that he probably didn't even exist.
When it comes to the Koran, someone pointed out how Arabic and Aramaic use the same script, and the languages are quite similar, and if you read certain passages as if it were originally Aramaic the Koran becomes a Christian prayer book. It is quite possible that the Arabs tried to read a Christian prayer book and got a lot of it wrong.
>When it comes to Islam, everything, literally EVERYTHING, we know about Mohammed comes hundreds and hundreds of years after he lived, and even then, the information does not correspond at all with archaeological or historical evidence. There is so little evidence of Mohammed that he probably didn't even exist.
100% correct. Nothing about him or what he allegedly said was ever written during his lifetime, which in itself makes one question whether he existed.
>It is quite possible that the Arabs tried to read a Christian prayer book and got a lot of it wrong.
That's what the Church has basically taught about Mohammadanism since Mohammadanism was born, some guy was wooed buy Arian Heretics, realized they were wrong about everything, and then created his own heresy but even stupider.
I believe one of the Shahs aggressively destroyed all the versions of the Quaran that he didnt personally like as well. There wasnt a council or anything like the Church Fathers condemning the Gnostic "Scriptures" and actually providing reasons why they were fake and gay, this guy just started destroying Quarans that didnt line up with his view of Mohammadenism.
My source for this is Robert Spencer, who has written extensively on these subjects.
When it comes to the Koran, someone pointed out how Arabic and Aramaic use the same script, and the languages are quite similar, and if you read certain passages as if it were originally Aramaic the Koran becomes a Christian prayer book. It is quite possible that the Arabs tried to read a Christian prayer book and got a lot of it wrong.
100% correct. Nothing about him or what he allegedly said was ever written during his lifetime, which in itself makes one question whether he existed.
That's what the Church has basically taught about Mohammadanism since Mohammadanism was born, some guy was wooed buy Arian Heretics, realized they were wrong about everything, and then created his own heresy but even stupider.
i wish people stopped being so lazy and read the quran and at least part of the hadiths. islam is such a farce it's not even funny