New here?
Create an account to submit posts, participate in discussions and chat with people.
Sign up
Long story short: Insects only attack dead or dying plants, and fertilizers do not make plants healthy.

Back in 2021, we were hit with a "150 year" drought here in NE Texas. We normally get something like 40" of rain every year, and the previous year was exceptionally wet.

That was also the first year I started doing regenerative ag through rotational grazing on my pasture. The previous owner probably sprayed herbicide and pesticide and fertilizer everywhere then planted ryegrass, because what I had was neatly planted rows of ryegrass up to my armpits.

Grasshoppers ate pretty much everything to the ground. I owned a patch of dry clay soil and a few weeds, along with some spots of bermudagrass that was completely brown.

The next year the grasshoppers were back, of course. There weren't enough chickens in the world to eat all of them. But curiously, in one spot of pasture, there were no grasshoppers, no weeds at all in fact. The bermudagrass had come in so strong an thick that everything else died. It couldn't compete. The area was completely free of grasshoppers too.

Then in 2023, even fewer grasshoppers. Now I saw legumes like clovers and hairy vetch and all sorts of flowering plants mixed in with the grass. The only areas the grasshoppers seemed to do well were the areas that were weak. The grasshoppers were tiny too.

And in 2024, I could barely find any grasshoppers at all. My wife liked to collect grasshoppers in soda bottles to feed the chickens, but that year she was only able to find a few.

In order to understand what is going on, let me introduce you to some powerful concepts. Concept #1 is that a high BRIX score (BRIX measures the sugar content of the leaf) means that insects won't touch it. This is because insects simply can't handle sugar. Concept #2 has to do with how the plant grows. Roughly, there are primary processes that produce sugars and starches and cellulose. These make the plant grow big and green. The secondary processes make the nutrients we expect the plant to have, the flavors and also things like wax and natural insecticides. Fertilizers overstimulate the plant to focus on primary processes. Dead soil can't support the secondary processes.

See, the minerals and nutrients that the plant needs are fed via the roots by bacteria, fungus, and even tiny insects. In healthy, living soil the plant and the soil communicate. The plant will actually send some of the sugars down to its roots. These sugars will create colonies of bacteria and such, and there is an entire lifecycle that happens, eventually leading to the nutrients the plant needs being made available for the plant.

There has already been tons of research into what exactly is happening in the soil, but it seems the more we learn the more questions we have. Right now, the "state of the art" is to stop messing with the soil, let the weeds grow, let the insects run free, and get Nature to do her thing. By using a light touch, we can encourage certain things to grow, or discourage other things. IE, by grazing animals grasses get a boost and weeds take a hit. But ultimately we can't fully control the entire process, and by mucking things up by throwing fertilizers in the ground, we are making all sorts of problems that we barely understand.

Why are your plants being devoured by insects? Simply put -- your plants are sick. They are dying. It may look green and leafy and tall, but if those secondary processes aren't happening, then not only are you denying yourself of valuable nutrients, but the insects are able to move in. You need to stop throwing fertilizer everywhere. Heck, even manure and compost can throw things out of balance, so be very careful.

Your focus as a farmer, a gardener, a rancher, whatever you do with nature, should be the soil. Do those things to build soil up naturally, don't mess with stuff you don't understand. Study nature, observe the patterns, and figure out how to use things to your advantage, but don't think that by trying to kill everything you are going to create thriving life.
You must log in or sign up to comment
11 comments:
Erase99 on scored.co
11 months ago 5 points (+0 / -0 / +5Score on mirror ) 1 child
Impossible OP. How can we feed the 7.9 billion Hindus we're planning to fill Europe without Roundup Ready (TM) crops?
systemthrowaway on scored.co
11 months ago 5 points (+0 / -0 / +5Score on mirror ) 1 child
Seriously if White people one day decided to only feed White people we wouldn't need industrial farming at all.
MI7BZ3EW on scored.co
11 months ago 2 points (+0 / -0 / +2Score on mirror )
THIS.
Diamond_R on scored.co
11 months ago 2 points (+0 / -0 / +2Score on mirror )
Increased atmospheric CO2 means that plants in general are healthier and in turn have healthier immune systems, which means that less fungicides and pesticides are required to keep the plants healthy. But If you're growing grasshopper food in a grasshopper rich environment that isn't going to help much.
bobbacringo on scored.co
11 months ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror )
Japanese beetles will eat healthy leaves of whatever they decide they like. Once saw all the Elm trees in my old neighborhood completely leafless and shimmering with Japanese beetles.
deleted 11 months ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror )
GoneViking on scored.co
11 months ago 1 point (+0 / -0 / +1Score on mirror ) 1 child
Saying "Insects only attack dead or dying plants" reeks of inexperience. I use no insecticides or herbicides in my large garden. The worms of cabbage moths, Colorado potato beetles, squash beetle, and Japanese beetles, among many others, definitely eat and destroy live and flourishing plants in my garden. There is no super secret method to farming or gardening or raising your own food that bypasses hard work and a bit of a fight every year.
MI7BZ3EW on scored.co
11 months ago 0 points (+0 / -0 ) 1 child
Think hard about what you just said.

Think hard about what I just said.

Just because your plants are big and green does not mean they are healthy.
GoneViking on scored.co
11 months ago 0 points (+0 / -0 )
Hahaha, ok. "Don't believe your lying eyes"
TiredDad on scored.co
11 months ago 0 points (+0 / -0 ) 1 child
By fertilizer I assume you meant the industrial one? I use manure and organic compost and they work very well (smell a bit though).

It is also my belief that insecticide and pesticide accentuate pest problems, as they grow resistance to those. It's better to cover your crops with net instead.
MI7BZ3EW on scored.co
11 months ago 0 points (+0 / -0 )
Too much nitrogen in the soil, even from natural sources, can be bad.

Imagine if you kept a bunch of cows at one spot in the pasture and their manure kept piling up. Would that create healthy soil? No, the soil would smell like shit and only weeds would ever grow there.
Toast message